This Office previously concluded that RIDOT violated the APRA when it failed to timely produce or exempt all documents responsive to Complainant's request. This Office issued a finding requiring RIDOT to provide any responsive documents it maintains at no cost, describe its search efforts, and address whether its violation should be considered willful and knowing or, alternatively, reckless. See PR 19-06. After receiving the supplemental submissions, this Office determined that injunctive relief was not appropriate and we did not find sufficient evidence of a willful and knowing, or reckless, violation.