The City of Cranston Building Department violated the APRA by failing to timely respond to two APRA requests hand-delivered on February 5, 2018. The City subsequently provided the complainant with documents and although the complainant alleged that other responsive documents were withheld by the City, we found no evidence to support this allegation. We also found no evidence that the City's failure to timely respond was the result of a willful and knowing, or reckless violation.